What is Display Sparkle?

High-frequency visual disturbances such as Display Sparkle or DeepGreyMura impair the perceived uniformity of a display. These can be particularly pronounced with anti-glare layers (AGL). Together with leading OEMs, TechnoTeam has therefore developed a standardized method for sparkle analysis that is now regarded as an industry benchmark. LMK Display Sparkle is part of the display package.

Lade Player...

Advantages & features at a glance

  • IEC 62977-3-9 compliant and integrated into OEM specifications
  • Sparkle measurement directly possible at any stage of development
  • Full compatibility with all TechnoTeam LMK 5 & LMK 6 luminance cameras (from 16 mm lens)
  • Reproducible results thanks to frequency filter & distance focus scan
  • Live view & automatic alignment with BlackMURA methodology

Measuring principle & procedure

  1. Selection of the camera/lens combination and initial measuring distance
  2. Alignment using Live View and BlackMURA method
  3. Focusing directly on the display pixels (within the moiré area)
  4. Measurement of a green test image with a luminance measurement camera (LMK)
  5. Automatic correction of unwanted influences (pixel structure, dust, moiré)
  6. Sparkle value is calculated in % in accordance with IEC 62977-3-9

Thanks to the algorithmic frequency filter, the results remain stable and comparable even with variable optical magnification.

Sparkle measurement setup table for different (BlackMURA compliant) LMK systems

Distance focus scan for optimum image sharpness

A special feature is the distance focus scan developed by TechnoTeam. This automatically determines the point of maximum sparkle sharpness exactly where the sparkle effect is most strongly perceived by the human eye. This is done either manually or via an optional motorized linear axis. Alternatively, an LMK Position system can be used.

Typical curve of a distance-focus sparkle scan from LabSoft.

 

FAQ — LMK Display Sparkle

LMK Display Sparkle is a LabSoft add-on for TechnoTeam's LMK 5 and LMK 6 luminance measurement cameras. It quantifies the high-frequency luminance non-uniformity known as sparkle, which appears on displays with an anti-glare layer (AGL). The measurement procedure is compliant with IEC 62977-3-9 and was co-developed by TechnoTeam, Volkswagen and Elektrobit. The add-on is part of TechnoTeam's display package.

A measurement combines a BlackMURA-compatible alignment, an automated distance focus scan that locates the focus position at which sparkle is most strongly perceived, and a frequency-filter evaluation that separates the high-frequency sparkle signal from the periodic pixel grid. The result is reported as sparkle contrast in percent.

Yes. Sparkle measurements depend on factors such as the angular aperture of the lens or the magnification at which the display is observed, among many others. All of these need to be documented for the result, as reproducibility would otherwise be limited. LMK Display Sparkle controls these factors automatically during the measurement and records them as part of the measurement protocol.

IEC 62977-3-9 does not prescribe a single processing algorithm. It permits several different methods to separate the sparkle signal from the underlying pixel matrix, and LMK Display Sparkle uses a frequency-filter approach to do so. The standard also does not define a numerical sparkle threshold. Acceptance criteria are set by the OEM or by the end-user specification.

The add-on works with all TechnoTeam LMK 5 and LMK 6 luminance cameras from 16 mm focal length upwards. The validated lens set is 16 mm, 25 mm and 50 mm. This includes the same standard lenses already used in BlackMURA setups.

A monochrome ILMD is required. Sparkle is evaluated on a single colour channel of a green test image, and an RGB Bayer-pattern sensor would distort the high-frequency signal through spectral crosstalk and demosaicing interpolation. The LMK 6 colour camera uses a filter wheel with a monochrome sensor and is fully compatible. The LMK 5 can also be used in combination with the current LabSoft, the LMK Display Sparkle add-on and a translation stage for the distance focus scan.

The same equipment — camera and lens — is used for both measurements, and the geometric alignment follows the same BlackMURA pattern and tolerances. A BlackMURA-compliant setup is therefore also a valid sparkle setup.

What can change between the two measurements is the measurement distance and focus. For larger panels in particular, the sparkle measurement may need a different distance than the BlackMURA capture you have already optimised. The measurement procedure includes a Fourier downsampling step that was designed precisely for this case: different measurement distances within the validated sampling window produce comparable sparkle values, so you can pick the distance that fits your panel and your cell without losing reproducibility.

The sparkle pattern does not necessarily lie exactly on the display pixel plane. It sits somewhere inside the depth of focus of the camera-lens combination, at a position that depends on the AGL, its position, and the display pixel geometry. Manual focus and autofocus alone cannot reliably find this position, because the signal level looks almost identical across the depth of focus. Without a focus scan, two operators can therefore read significantly different sparkle values from the same panel, purely as a result of focus.

The distance focus scan resolves this. The camera is moved over a small distance range, a sparkle value is calculated at each step, and the maximum value is taken as the result. That maximum corresponds to the focus position at which the human eye perceives sparkle most strongly, and it is reproducible across operators and setups. The scan only has to be run when the setup or the panel type changes; for repeated measurements on the same panel it does not need to be repeated.

The distance focus scan can be performed manually, with an optional motorised linear axis, or fully automatically as part of an LMK Position 6-axis robotic system. A manual translation stage is the simplest and most economical option and is well suited to engineering labs. A motorised axis removes the manual hand-wheel and is typical for repeated measurements. The LMK Position system performs the BlackMURA-compatible alignment and the distance focus scan automatically and was also the platform used for the original setup-sensitivity studies that derived the procedure.

Sparkle can be measured at any stage of the lifecycle, because our procedure does not require physical separation of the AGL from the display. The same measurement can be applied to coated cover glass on a reference display, to a sub-assembly, or to a finished display module, which means the same procedure covers AGL development, supplier qualification and incoming inspection. The validation set used to derive the procedure included both glass-based and foil-based AGLs and displays with different PPI, so the typical real-world configurations are covered.

It does, within practical limits. Sparkle is not evaluated over the full display surface; the measurement uses a representative region — typically near the centre — where the camera resolves the pixel structure. For displays with low to moderate curvature this is unproblematic. For displays with stronger curvature, choose a setup with a larger depth of focus so that the local curvature does not push the evaluation region out of focus. The procedure itself — alignment, distance focus scan, frequency-filter evaluation — is unchanged.

Reproducibility starts with the hardware and the setup, not with software alone. LMK Display Sparkle specifies a defined range of cameras (LMK 5 / LMK 6, monochrome) and lenses (16 mm, 25 mm, 50 mm) and a defined measurement window — sampling resolution, angular aperture, alignment tolerances — that has been validated to produce comparable sparkle values across that range. When you stay within this window, you are using a setup TechnoTeam has qualified for the method.

Within that window, the measurement software smooths out the remaining differences between setups. The distance focus scan removes the operator dependence on the focus position, Fourier downsampling normalizes the result to a common reference frequency so that two different magnifications produce comparable values, and image averaging keeps the contribution of sensor noise under control. These algorithmic steps extend the practical flexibility of the method, but the foundation is still the right hardware in the right setup.

This combination was validated in a round-robin experiment with three independent labs, three different ILMDs and operators who had not been involved in developing the procedure. The same panels read comparable sparkle values across all three labs, for both glass-based and foil-based AGLs.

Publications

International Display Workshop (IDW 2022)

This contribution examines the influence of ILMD noise on the reproducibility of different sparkle evaluation setups. Sparkle measurements at different sampling rates and aperture numbers are simulated for different ILMD sensors. Especially at low sparkle levels, the SNR can become very critical for some evaluation techniques such that the number of measurements needs to be increased significantly to ensure reproducibility among the different ILMD sensors.
Authors: I. Rotscholl, U. Krüger

Journal of the Society for Information Display

This contribution proposes a sparkle evaluation based on a spatial frequency filter, taking into account various setup influences. Furthermore, the effect of flexible setup conditions on the reproducibility of measurement results is investigated. The procedure and concepts are derived for sampling resolutions between 15 and 30 cpx/mm with display pixel pitches between 183 and 224 ppi and validated by a round-robin experiment with different test devices, including glass and foil-based anti-glare layers. The findings serve as a basis for the measurement conditions of an automotive display sparkle measurement specification.
Authors: I. Rotscholl; A. Schlipf; C. Rickers; U. Krüger

International Conference on Display Technology (ICDT 2020)

The reproducible quantification of anti-glare layer based display sparkle with Imaging Luminance Measurement Devices (ILMD) is essential for testing and conformity assessment of many displays intended for outdoor applications. This study systematically investigates relevant setup and system influences of a Fourier space-based sparkle evaluation. These include 13 different anti-glare layers, two displays with different PPI, and several different system setups featuring 12 different camera/lens combinations and more than 10,000 individual luminance images. Based on the resulting sensitivities, the measurement procedure is optimized with respect to the achieved reproducibility. The resulting procedure serves as a basis to define a new automotive specification for reproducible sparkle measurements and may do so for other applications that need to quantify sparkle in a reproducible way.
Authors: I. Rotscholl; J. Rasmussen; C. Rickers; J. Brinkmann; B. Liu; U. Krüger

International Display Workshop (IDW 2021)

This contribution evaluates a frequency-filter based sparkle evaluation and investigates the compromise between reproducible measurement results and flexible setup conditions. It is based on measurements with two displays and 9 AGLs. The findings serve as a basis for the measurement conditions of an upcoming automotive display sparkle measurement specification.
Authors: I. Rotscholl; A. Schlipf, C. Rickers, U. Krüger
Type:
Add-On
Applications:
Automotive Display
Measurands:
Light measurement
Tasks:
Development & Industry